Class Size Impact on Student Achievement: Research

Does smaller mean better when it comes to class sizes? Here's what the research says:

• Smaller classes (13-17 students) can boost achievement, especially in early grades (K-3)
• Reading and math scores improve most
• Low-income and minority students often benefit more
• Long-term effects include higher college attendance rates
• But smaller classes are expensive - cutting 1 student per class costs $12 billion/year
• Teacher quality matters as much as (or more than) class size
• Effects vary by country, subject, and grade level

Key findings from major studies:

Study	Results
Tennessee STAR	Small classes (13-17) outperformed regular classes (22-25) by 3-4 months of learning after 4 years
Texas	Positive effects, but about half as large as STAR
California CSR	Mixed results - some gains offset by influx of new teachers
Wisconsin SAGE	Similar benefits to STAR in high-poverty schools

Bottom line: Smaller classes can help, but they're not a magic fix. Schools must weigh costs vs. benefits and consider other ways to improve learning.

Related video from YouTube

Main Research Studies

The Tennessee STAR Project is the big kahuna of class size studies. Let's dive into its findings and other key research:

The Tennessee STAR Project

This massive study involved 7,000+ students across 79 schools in the late 1980s. Here's the scoop:

• Kids were randomly put into:
  • Small classes (13-17 students)
  • Regular classes (22-25 students)
  • Regular classes with a teacher's aide
• They tracked these kids from kindergarten through 3rd grade

The results? Pretty impressive:

Grade	Months Ahead in Small Classes
Kindergarten	0.5
1st	1.9
2nd	5.6
3rd	7.1

But wait, there's more:

• By 8th grade, small-class kids were:
  • 4.1 months ahead in reading
  • 3.4 months ahead in math
  • 4.3 months ahead in science
  • 4.8 months ahead in social science
• At age 20, they were 2% more likely to be in college

The takeaway? Smaller classes pack a punch, especially for disadvantaged students.

Other Key Studies

While STAR is the heavyweight champ, other studies have thrown their hats in the ring:

1. Texas Study

Saw positive effects, but about half as big as STAR's.

2. Israel Study

Also found benefits from smaller classes, but not as dramatic as STAR.

3. California's K-3 CSR Program

Aimed to slash class sizes from 30 to 20 students. The results were a mixed bag:

• Some positive effects
• But these were offset by an influx of rookie teachers

4. Wisconsin's SAGE Program

Focused on high-poverty districts, aiming for 15 students per teacher in K-3. Early findings showed:

• Bigger gains in achievement scores
• Results similar to STAR

The bottom line? Smaller classes often help, but it's not a magic bullet. Teacher experience and implementation matter big time.

Factors That Change Class Size Effects

Class size impacts student achievement, but it's not a simple fix. Here's how different factors change the effects of smaller classes:

Grade Levels

Class size impact varies:

Grade Level	Effect
Elementary	Strongest
Middle	Moderate
High School	Less clear

The Tennessee STAR Project found kids in small classes (13-17 students) in early grades gained up to 7.1 months of extra learning by 3rd grade. These benefits stuck around into high school and beyond.

Subjects

Class size doesn't affect all subjects the same:

• Reading: Often sees bigger gains
• Math: Improves, but less than reading
• Science and Social Studies: Mixed results, but generally positive

Student Background

Some students benefit more from smaller classes:

• Low-income students: Often see the biggest gains
• Minority students: Tend to benefit more than average
• High-performing students: Still benefit, but less dramatically

The STAR project found Black students and those from low-income families improved the most in small classes.

Teacher Skill

Teacher quality is key:

• Experienced teachers: Make the most of small classes
• New teachers: Often struggle, even with fewer students

A STAR data study found only senior teachers created real benefits from smaller classes. New teachers in small classes performed about the same as experienced teachers in regular-sized classes.

"Policy advice suggests assigning senior teachers to small classes and inexperienced teachers to regular size classes to maximize average student achievement." - STAR Project Analysis

Bottom line? Smaller classes can help, but they're not a cure-all. The right mix of experienced teachers, targeted grade levels, and focus on the most-helped students can make class size reduction work better.

Effects on Grades and Learning

Class size impacts student grades and learning. Here's how smaller classes affect different subjects:

Reading Skills

Smaller classes often boost reading skills more than other subjects. The Tennessee STAR Project found:

Class Size	Reading Improvement
13-17 students	Up to 0.22 standard deviations higher
22-25 students	Baseline

These gains lasted years after students moved to regular-sized classes.

"Students in small classes outperformed their peers by about 0.22 standard deviations after four years." - Tennessee STAR Project findings

Math Skills

Math also improves in smaller classes, but less than reading:

• Texas study: 4th graders in smaller classes did better in math
• Effects faded by 5th grade
• STAR Project: Math gains similar to reading, but slightly smaller

Other School Subjects

Research on other subjects is mixed:

• Science and social studies: Some positive effects, but less clear
• Overall grades: Often improve in smaller classes

The STAR Project showed benefits across subjects, especially for low-income students, Black students, and boys.

"The positive effects of class size were largest for black students, economically disadvantaged students, and boys." - STAR Project analysis

But here's the thing: smaller classes aren't a magic fix. Some studies, like one in Minnesota, found tiny gains from big class size cuts. Others, like in Connecticut and Florida, saw no test score boost at all.

So what's the deal? Smaller classes CAN help, but it's not that simple. Teacher quality, resources, and how schools use smaller classes all play a role in student success.

Effects Beyond Grades

Class size doesn't just affect grades. It shapes behavior, relationships, and the classroom vibe.

Student Behavior and Participation

Smaller classes often mean better behavior and more participation:

• Big classes? More distractions.
• Small classes? Shy kids speak up.

A study of 5-year-olds found:

Class Size	Behavior
Small (avg. 19)	Less off-task
Large (avg. 33)	More distractions

But here's a twist:

"Smallest classes showed slightly worse peer relations, with more aggression and exclusion."

So, smaller isn't always better for social skills.

Student-Teacher Connections

Smaller classes can boost student-teacher bonds:

• More one-on-one time
• Students feel valued

But a survey of 25,400 students showed:

Grade	Strong Teacher Relationships
Middle School	< 33%
12th Grade	16%

Low-income students? Even lower numbers.

How to fix this?

• Train staff on building relationships
• Create one-on-one time
• Value these bonds

Classroom Environment

Class size affects the classroom vibe:

• 15-20 students? More supportive
• Larger classes? More cliques

The Tenney School found 3-7 student groups were more social than 20-student classes.

Stephanie Burroughs says:

"Strong student relationships mean stronger school communities."

Why does this matter? The CDC found connected students make healthier choices.

Smaller classes can help, but they're not magic. Schools need to weigh costs and benefits, and explore other ways to improve learning.

Costs vs. Benefits

Smaller classes sound great, but they're not cheap. Let's look at the costs and compare them to other ways to spend education money.

The Price of Shrinking Classes

Cutting class sizes hits the wallet hard:

• More teachers to pay
• Extra classrooms needed

In the U.S., dropping just ONE student per class would cost $12 billion a year in teacher salaries. And that's not even counting the 225,000 new classrooms needed.

Students Cut	Yearly Cost
1	$12 billion
5	$60 billion

Norway tried something different. They set a "teacher density" goal instead of strict class limits. Their budget? 49 million euros over four years to study the effects.

Other Ways to Spend the Cash

Some experts say there are smarter ways to use education funds:

1. Boost teacher quality

Swapping out the bottom 5-8% of teachers for average ones could skyrocket U.S. student achievement.

2. Targeted class size cuts

Focus on groups that benefit most, like disadvantaged kids in early grades.

3. Train teachers better

Help teachers level up their skills.

4. Improve curriculum

Create and use more effective teaching materials.

Matthew M. Chingos from the Brookings Institution puts it bluntly:

"Large-scale CSR policies clearly fail any cost-benefit test because they entail steep costs and produce benefits that are modest at best."

But it's not all doom and gloom for smaller classes. The Tennessee STAR Project found the economic returns beat the costs, with a 6% internal rate of return.

The takeaway? Smaller classes can work, but they're pricey. Schools need to think hard about whether they're getting the most bang for their buck.

sbb-itb-7aa0ffe

Research Challenges

Studying class size impact on learning isn't straightforward. Here's why:

Problems in Studying Class Size

1. Too Many Variables

It's hard to isolate class size effects from other factors like:

• Teacher quality
• Student backgrounds
• School resources

These all influence student success.

2. Mixed Results

Studies often contradict each other:

Study Outcome	Number of Studies
Favor smaller classes	35
Inconclusive	32
Favor larger classes	18

This makes drawing firm conclusions tough.

3. Narrow Focus

Most research only looks at reading and math scores. What about behavior, relationships, and non-cognitive skills?

Weaknesses in Current Research

1. Old Data

Key studies, like the Tennessee STAR project, are from decades ago. We need fresh data.

2. Limited Scope

Many studies use small sample sizes, limiting their applicability.

3. Ignoring Teaching Methods

"Most discussions of reducing class size begin with an assertion that student performance will increase if only class sizes can be reduced, a proposition shown to be generally erroneous." - Eric A. Hanushek, Economist

This quote nails it: Many studies don't consider how teachers adapt (or don't) to smaller classes.

4. Cultural Blind Spots

Class size effects can vary between countries. Smaller classes might matter more in resource-poor areas.

5. Fixation on Test Scores

Grades aren't everything. Research often misses long-term impacts, social-emotional learning, and classroom dynamics.

To get the full picture, we need to broaden our research approach.

Class Size Around the World

Class size varies globally, affecting student learning differently. Let's explore:

Country Differences

Class sizes differ significantly:

Country	Primary	Lower Secondary
United States	21.1	26.7
Brazil	23.0	27.0
India	23.5	22.4
Japan	27.3	32.3
China	37.5	48.8

The U.S. has slightly larger classes than the OECD average. Asian countries often have bigger classes. Surprisingly, high-achieving countries like Japan and Korea have the largest class sizes.

Cultural Impact

Culture shapes how class size affects learning:

1. Asian Approach

Large classes work well in many Asian countries. Why?

• Strong discipline
• Students work well in big groups
• Less classroom management needed

In Taiwan, 50-student classes were once common. Many learned well in these big groups.

2. Western View

Western countries often prefer smaller classes. The idea? More attention equals better learning.

But research is mixed:

• Tennessee STAR study found benefits in smaller classes
• Other studies show little effect on performance

3. Developing Countries

Large classes are often necessary:

• India has classes up to 65 students
• Success often linked to parental involvement

4. Public vs Private

The gap between public and private school class sizes varies:

• U.S. private primary schools average 19.4 students vs 23.6 in public
• Some countries have smaller public primary classes than private ones

The New York Times notes:

"Perhaps this has to do with cultural differences; societies with Confucian roots may have stricter hierarchies within the classroom, so perhaps it's easier (or more expected) for a single teacher to manage a bigger group of students."

This shows how culture shapes class size impact on learning.

Advice for Schools and Policymakers

Where to Reduce Class Size

Want to shrink class sizes? Start with the little ones. Focus on kindergarten through third grade. Why? The Tennessee STAR project showed it works best for these youngsters.

Here's how to do it:

1. Kick off in kindergarten or pre-K
2. Move up to third grade, step by step
3. Aim for 15 kids per teacher

Charles Achilles, a big name in education, puts it this way:

"Smaller classes for young learners? That's step one in making American education world-class."

Short on cash? Try these tricks:

• Shrink classes for kids who need it most
• Use small groups in big classes
• Mix up groups based on what kids need

Adapting to Different Schools

One size doesn't fit all. Schools need to think about:

• Who their students are
• What resources they have
• How big their classes are now

Here's what it might cost to shrink classes:

Current Size	Cost per Kid (to 20)	Cost per Kid (to 17)	Cost per Kid (to 15)
24	$435	$870	$1,305
25	$515	$950	$1,385
26	$595	$1,030	$1,465

Note: This assumes each classroom costs $53,000. Add $80 per kid for each extra student in the current class.

Can't shrink all classes? Try these:

1. Target key subjects: Think reading and math.

2. Use small groups: 15-30 minute sessions in big classes work wonders.

3. Keep checking: See how kids are doing and switch things up.

4. Train teachers: Show them how to rock small-group teaching.

5. Team up: The SAGE project found two teachers in a big class can be a win.

Future Research Needs

We've learned a lot about class size, but big questions remain. Here's what we need to figure out:

What We Still Don't Know

1. High school impacts

Most studies look at younger kids. How does class size affect teens?

2. Online learning

As virtual classes grow, does size matter online?

3. Long-term outcomes

Do smaller classes lead to better jobs or higher pay?

4. Teacher methods

How do teachers change their approach in smaller classes?

5. Cost-benefit analysis

Are smaller classes worth the money compared to other school improvements?

New Research Questions

To move forward, we should ask:

• How does class size impact different subjects?
• Do effects vary by student background or ability?
• What's the ideal class size for each grade?
• How do school resources and teacher quality mix with class size?

Fresh approaches:

1. Use current data

Many studies use old info. We need research on today's classrooms.

2. Look beyond test scores

Measure things like student engagement and creativity.

3. Study real-world changes

Track results when schools adjust class sizes.

4. Compare internationally

Learn from countries with different class sizes.

5. Examine teacher perspectives

Ask educators how class size affects their work.

"The research literature has focused on the effect of reducing class size, but the current policy debate concerns the consequences of increasing the size of classes." - Brookings Institution report

This shift shows we need to study larger classes, not just smaller ones.

Research Area	Key Questions
High School	How does class size affect college readiness?
Online Learning	Is there an ideal virtual class size?
Long-Term Effects	Do smaller classes lead to higher earnings?
Teacher Methods	Which teaching styles work best in small classes?
Cost-Benefit	How do class size reductions compare to other changes?

Conclusion

The class size debate isn't going away. Here's what we've learned:

• Smaller classes help younger kids most, especially in reading and math
• Results aren't always clear-cut
• Cutting class size costs a lot
• Effects change based on grade, subject, and student background

What This Means

Class size matters, but it's complicated. Let's break it down:

1. Project STAR showed big gains

• Reading scores up 8%
• Math scores up 9%
• More kids taking college entrance exams

2. Money talks

Smaller classes are pricey:

• Cutting one student per class? That's $12 billion in teacher pay
• Right now, U.S. public schools average 15.3 students per teacher

3. Where it works best

• Early grades (K-3)
• Kids who need extra help

4. Good teachers are key

Small classes aren't enough. You need quality teaching too.

5. We need fresh data

Most studies are old news. We need to look at today's classrooms.

Smaller Classes: Pros	Smaller Classes: Cons
Better test scores	Costs a ton
More one-on-one time	Not enough teachers
Kids behave better	Some studies say it doesn't help
More kids ready for college	Might not work for all grades

So, what's the answer? We don't know for sure. But smart class size cuts can help some kids. Schools need to balance size with other stuff like good teachers and resources.

FAQs

What does research say about small classes and their effects?

Studies show smaller classes can boost student achievement, especially in early grades. Here's the scoop:

The Tennessee STAR Project found students in classes of 15 outperformed those in classes of 22 by about 3 months of schooling after 4 years.

Grade-level effects varied:

• 4th grade: Clear benefits in reading and math
• 5th grade: Smaller, but noticeable gains
• Later grades: Little to no effect

Long-term, STAR students in small classes for 3+ years were more likely to graduate high school.

By 8th grade, students in smaller classes were ahead in multiple subjects:

• Reading: 4.1 months
• Math: 3.4 months
• Science: 4.3 months
• Social science: 4.8 months

"The researchers found positive effects of smaller class sizes on reading and mathematics in 4th grade, a smaller but still statistically significant effect in 5th grade, and little or no effects in later grades." - May 11, 2011

But remember: smaller classes aren't a silver bullet. Teacher quality and student background also play big roles in learning outcomes.